How To Choose a Roofing Contractor

When the time comes for a homeowner to replace or repair their roof, the most important decision to be made is how to choose a roofing contractor. This selection is far from a simple one; it requires thorough consideration and careful planning. The right roofing contractor ensures a hassle-free process and a well-executed project, while the wrong choice could lead to complications, excess costs, and an inferior result.

Understanding the Importance of Roofing

Before delving into the process of choosing a roofing contractor, it’s important to comprehend the critical role a roof plays in the home. It’s not just a top cover; a roof provides essential protection to the home against various weather conditions, maintaining comfort and security. A well-installed roof can greatly enhance the aesthetic value of the house and also contribute to its energy efficiency. Therefore, entrusting its maintenance or replacement to a proficient contractor is paramount.

Contractor’s Licensing and Insurance


One of the key aspects when selecting a roofing contractor is ensuring that they possess the necessary licensing and insurance. A valid license shows that the contractor has met specific standards set by the local or state regulatory authorities, ensuring they possess the skills and knowledge to do the job competently.

Insurance, on the other hand, is a safety net for both the homeowner and the contractor. It guarantees that the homeowner will not be held liable for any accidents or injuries that occur on their property during the project. It also assures the homeowner that any damages to the property during the construction phase will be compensated.

Reviewing the Contractor’s Past Work

Past performance is a strong indicator of future performance. Therefore, reviewing a contractor’s past projects and clients’ feedback is an integral step. This information can typically be found on the contractor’s website or third-party review sites. Take the time to scrutinize these reviews, looking for patterns of positive or negative feedback.

Also, consider asking for references from past clients. A reputable contractor will readily provide references and may even take you to some of their completed projects. This gives you an opportunity to see the quality of their work and to hear firsthand experiences from their previous clients.

Evaluating Communication and Professionalism

Clear and consistent communication is vital in any construction project. It ensures everyone is on the same page regarding expectations, timelines, and potential issues. The roofing contractor should be ready to answer all your questions, explain the process, and keep you informed throughout the project.

Professionalism also plays a significant role. A professional contractor respects your time, keeps their commitments, and maintains a clean and safe job site. They should also provide a written contract detailing the scope of the project, costs, and timelines.

Considering the Price

While it might be tempting to choose the contractor offering the lowest bid, this could be a costly mistake. Very low bids may indicate subpar materials, lack of experience, or insufficient insurance and licensing. Remember, you often get what you pay for. Instead, aim for a balance between quality and cost, ensuring you receive value for your money.

Asking About Warranties

Ensure your contractor offers a warranty on both materials and workmanship. The manufacturer’s warranty covers any defects in the roofing materials, while the workmanship warranty protects you in case of installation errors. A contractor who doesn’t offer a warranty could leave you footing the bill for any issues that arise after the project’s completion.

The Importance of Local Experience

Choosing a local roofing contractor can offer several advantages, one of them being familiarity with regional weather conditions and local building codes. Contractors with local experience will be well-versed in selecting materials and utilizing techniques that can stand up to the climate in your specific region. Additionally, they’re often more familiar with local permit processes and code requirements, which helps ensure a smoother project timeline.

Local contractors also have a reputation to uphold within their community, which often leads to a higher standard of work. Plus, they are typically easier to contact for follow-up repairs or warranty claims, given their close proximity.

Manufacturer Certifications

Not all roofing contractors are the same. An excellent way to separate the best from the rest is by looking at manufacturer certifications. Roofing manufacturers award certifications to contractors who have completed their training and adhere to their high standards of installation.

Such certifications offer an additional layer of protection to homeowners as manufacturers usually back their certified contractors with extended warranties. If your contractor is certified, it demonstrates their commitment to quality work and up-to-date knowledge of installation techniques and products.

Involvement in Trade Associations

Membership in trade associations can also be an indicator of a reputable roofing contractor. These memberships show that the contractor values professional development and stays updated with the latest industry standards and practices. Some notable roofing and contractor associations include the National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA) and the Roofing Contractors Association of your specific state.

Detailed Project Proposal

An essential part of the process of selecting a roofing contractor is the proposal they provide. This proposal should detail the scope of the work, including removal of the old roof, installation of the new roof, cleanup, and disposal of waste. It should also specify the materials to be used, including the type and color of the shingles, underlayment type, and ventilation products.

The proposal should also specify the project’s cost, proposed start and end dates, and payment procedures. This document is crucial as it helps you understand what you’re paying for, allowing you to compare it with other proposals.

Understanding Contract Terms and Payment Options

Different contractors may offer different terms of payment. Some may require a deposit, while others might offer financing options. It’s essential to understand these terms before committing to a contractor. A contractor should never demand full payment up-front; it’s customary to agree on a partial upfront payment, with the remainder due after project completion and satisfaction.

The contract you sign should clearly outline the terms of payment, the project timeline, and the scope of work. Never start a project without a signed contract, and be sure to read and understand all terms and conditions before signing.

Contractor’s Staffing and Equipment


A reliable roofing contractor should have a team of experienced installers and adequate equipment to handle the job. The team should be skilled in the type of roof system you’re installing. If a contractor subcontracts the work, it’s important to know the qualifications of those workers too.

Furthermore, the contractor should have the necessary equipment for safety and installation. They should follow the Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s safety regulations to protect their workers and prevent accidents on their property.

Dealing with Unexpected Roofing Issues

Even with a thorough initial inspection, unexpected issues may arise once the old roof is removed. These can include rotten decking, weakened supports, or previous work that wasn’t up to code. A good roofing contractor will document these issues, explain your options, and provide a written estimate for the additional work. This approach ensures you’re not hit with unexpected costs and helps maintain the project’s integrity and safety.

Making an Informed Decision

Choosing a roofing contractor is a significant decision that should not be taken lightly. Consider their licensing, insurance, past work, communication, professionalism, price, and warranties. While this process may seem daunting, investing your time in careful consideration will result in a successful roofing project that adds value to your home and peace of mind to your life.

Leave a Reply